Lighthouse Strollo's Homemade Italian Ice is a specialty ice cream shop known for offering a variety of traditional and innovative Italian ice flavors alongside soft serve options. The shop provides a casual and inviting atmosphere, ideal for enjoying a refreshing treat after outdoor activities or during warm weather. Customers can expect a straightforward, cash-only service style that emphasizes quick and friendly interactions.
The establishment is recognized for its focus on fresh and flavorful ingredients, presenting a range of fruit-based Italian ices that balance sweetness and tartness without being overpowering. Alongside classic options, the shop also features unique flavors that appeal to diverse tastes. Soft serve offerings complement the Italian ices, adding variety for visitors seeking different textures and experiences.
Prices are generally reasonable, making it an accessible choice for families, individuals, and groups looking for a light, enjoyable dessert. While the shop does not widely advertise extended hours, it is noted for accommodating customers during key daytime and evening periods, supporting spontaneous visits after busy days.
Those interested in the full selection of flavors and combinations are encouraged to explore the dedicated menu page for more detailed information about the offerings at Lighthouse Strollo's Homemade Italian Ice.
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
1286 NJ-35, Middletown Township, NJ 07748, United States
6a King St, London W6 0QA, United Kingdom
45280, Toledo, Spain
Wülflingerstrasse 227A, 8408 Winterthur, Switzerland
Bogenstraße 2, 90530 Wendelstein, Germany
Coyuya 201, Santa Anita, Iztacalco, 08300 Ciudad de México, CDMX, Mexico
Discover new menus and trending dishes on Menustic.
Menustic helps you discover menus from restaurants, cafés, and bars around the world. Explore destinations, compare dishes and prices, and decide where to eat or drink — Fantastic Menus, One Click Away.
© 2026 Menustic. Built to help people discover menus and decide what to eat and drink.
Kassandra Mancino
25/03/2026
Hands down the best ice cream ever! I seriously can’t stop craving it. The vibes are amazing—especially after a hot day at the pool, it hits the spot perfectly. Everything was super fresh and flavorful, and the prices were really reasonable too. I absolutely loved it and will 100% be back again. If you’re looking for that perfect summer treat, this is the place!
Gia !
21/02/2026
• strawberry soft ice cream - i actually prefer hard ice cream although this was surprisingly good. i don’t like excessive fruit drizzles but the strawberry wasn’t too sweet or artificial flavored. • lemon italian ice - suuuuuuper sour. very bright and refreshing. if you’re familiar with del’s lemonade, then this is a way better version. notes they close late which is perfect because i was craving dessert after a concert. overall, solid.
Thomas P Smith NY REAL ESTATE
09/02/2026
Very good ice soft serve italian ice is a treat. We had cherry and lemon but they had so many flavors to choose from. Coming off a hot beach you couldn’t pick a better location.
Anjali Patel
22/01/2026
I love this place! My favorite place for Italian ice! Cherry, Blue Raspberry and Lime are some of my favorite flavors!!!
Jessica Beck
17/01/2026
Fresh, refreshing, delicious! Orange, lemon, and mango are favs! Root beer is yummy too. The soft serve was tasty, but we only sampled because we love the ice so much! The parking lots and handicapped parking are greatly appreciated, as are the tables. All employees have been polite and helpful at every location we've visited. Definitely worth the stop! Cash only! (Would be better if they accepted cards.)
Mark Farwell
09/01/2026
I mean it's Strollo's! An establishment in this area of Jersey. Some of the best traditional Italian ice you can get. Super silky and always delicious. Peanut butter was a surprisingly good flavor! I such a kid and still love my orange, blue rasp, and vanilla ice cream together. Which by the way the vanilla soft serve is some of the best. I always have to stop here while in the area! You should too.
Cheryl Bacigalupi
29/12/2025
Delicious Italian ices and friendly staff. I like root beer ice with vanilla ice cream. The lemon, orange, cherry and blue raspberry are all great. They also have non traditional flavors.
Nina Grigoriev
26/12/2025
Such a good vibe!Got the chocolate soft serve,lemon italian ice and orange ice,and blue raspberry. So yummy and not too sweet